It’s a conversation we’ve seen happen in our dealership, and all over the internet: Should I buy a new Ford F-150 or a new GMC Sierra?
Both offer beefy engines, cabins that can seat between three to six passengers, great safety features and modern infotainment. So which one should you choose?
First things first…
We’re a Ford Dealership that sells hundreds of new Ford F-150s every year. We live and die by the famous F-150, so we’re a little biased.
But only a little bit.
We’re going to keep this guide as objective as humanly possible. Because at the end of the day, we’re people too – and our goal at Lakeland Ford is always to help you find the best vehicle, whether it’s a Ford or not.
So without further adieu…
Comparing The F-150 & Sierra Engine Specs & Fuel Economy
Both the F-150 and the GMC Sierra 1500 offer a good balance of power and fuel economy.
Both trucks are equipped with a ten-speed automatic transmission across most engines, with the notable exception of the 2.7L turbo high-output engine on the Sierra 1500, which is matched with an eight-speed automatic transmission.
Switch between drive modes with either the traction select system on the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 or the selectable drive modes on the Ford F-150. The GMC Sierra 1500 can switch between tour, sport, terrain, snow, tow/haul, and off-road. The F-150 drive modes include: normal, eco, sport, tow/haul, slippery, trail, deep snow/sand, mud/rut, rock crawl, baja, and off-road.
2023 Ford F-150 Engine Options
The 2023 Ford F-150 comes with 7 engine configurations
|2.7L EcoBoost V6
|20 / 26
|3.5L EcoBoost V6
|18 / 24
|3.5L PowerBoost V6
|25 / 25
|3.3L Ti-VCT V6
|19 / 24
|5.0L Ti-VCT V8
|17 / 25
|High-output 3.5L EcoBoost V6
|15 / 18
|High-output 5.2L V8
|10 / 15
With the Raptor’s high output 5.2L V8 engine, you can get an eye-watering 700 HP if that’s your kind of thing. But how does the GMC Sierra 1500 compare?
2023 GMC Sierra 1500 Engine Options
Meanwhile, the GMC Sierra 1500 comes to the table with 4 engine options.
|2.7L Turbo V6
|19 / 22
|3.0L Duramax Turbo-Diesel
|24 / 29
|16 / 21
|15 / 19
GMC Sierra vs Ford F-150 Performance
The engine options are great on both trucks with Ford offering 6 engine options starting at the 3.3L Ti-VCT V6 and moving all the way up to the H.O. EcoBoost® Twin-Turbocharged V6 with 450 horsepower. GMC offers 5 engines starting with the 4.3L EcoTec3 V6 and going all the way up to the 6.2L V8 engine with 8-speed transmission that outputs 420 horsepower. Ford and GM teamed up to develop a 10-speed transmission together that provides quick and smooth acceleration.
Both trucks also have a diesel option. Ford has the 3.0L Power Stroke® Turbo Diesel V6 with 250 horsepower and 440 lb.-ft. of torque while GMC has the 3.0L Duramax® 1-6 Turbo-Diesel that outputs 277 horsepower and 460 lb.-ft. of torque. The Sierra has a slight edge in the diesel category but only slightly.
While the engine and transmission are important, the suspension is very crucial as well. The Sierra has a slightly smoother handling and ride quality than the F-150 but this point can be argued both ways. Both trucks handle very well in tough conditions, and each truck has effective 4WD.
In terms of exterior design, the 2023 Ford F-150 stands out with its muscular and bold appearance. It features a wide signature grille and offers two-tone exterior paint options, making it visually striking. Moreover, the F-150 incorporates premium lighting and durable components, not only enhancing its aesthetics but also ensuring long-lasting functionality. These design choices make the F-150 a compelling choice for those who seek a truck that combines style with durability.
On the other hand, the 2023 GMC Sierra maintains a more conservative approach to design, with its exterior largely unchanged from the previous model. However, it does feature a distinctive large glossy black front that gives it a bold and unique look. While the Sierra may not offer the same level of design innovation as the F-150, its focus on a glossy black front grille and its overall unchanged design may appeal to those who prefer a more traditional and classic truck appearance. Ultimately, the choice between these two models will come down to individual preferences, with the F-150 emphasizing innovation and the Sierra maintaining a timeless aesthetic.
Interior Design & Technology
When comparing the interior designs of the 2023 Ford F-150 and the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500, it’s evident that both trucks prioritize comfort and modernity. However, they do so in slightly different ways. The Ford F-150 excels in offering a deluxe cabin experience that rivals high-end sedans.
It emphasizes opulence, with plush seating, meticulous attention to detail, and a layout designed for driver comfort. The F-150 seamlessly integrates the latest technology, providing advanced infotainment systems and intuitive controls. Moreover, it boasts advanced specifications like adaptive ambient lighting and ergonomic seating adjustments, enhancing the overall driving experience. The F-150’s interior design is often regarded as sophisticated and elegant, with a harmonious blend of materials, textures, and colors.
In contrast, the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 focuses on spaciousness and premium quality. It offers generous legroom and well-cushioned seats for utmost passenger comfort during long or short journeys. The Sierra’s interior exudes luxury with high-quality materials, a prominent touchscreen display, and intricate detailing. It also caters to tech enthusiasts with features like Bose speakers and Electronic Precision Shift for smoother gear transitions. GMC’s commitment to quality is evident throughout the interior, from the soft-touch materials to the durable knobs and switches. Additionally, the Sierra provides a wide range of interior color options for personalization.
In summary, the Ford F-150 impresses with its opulent and innovative interior design, while the GMC Sierra 1500 focuses on spaciousness, premium materials, and a tech-forward approach. The choice between them will largely depend on individual preferences, with the F-150 offering a blend of luxury and modernity and the Sierra emphasizing comfort and upscale quality.
Safety Options & Features
When comparing the safety and security features of the 2023 Ford F-150 and the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500, it’s evident that both trucks prioritize the well-being of their occupants, but they do so with some differences. The Ford F-150 excels with its Automatic Emergency Braking and Pedestrian Detection systems, which can automatically apply the brakes in collision scenarios and alert the driver to pedestrians in the vehicle’s path. These features are particularly valuable for city driving and pedestrian safety. Additionally, the F-150 boasts top safety ratings from both the NHTSA and the IIHS, reinforcing its commitment to overall safety.
On the other hand, the 2023 GMC Sierra 1500 offers unique safety features such as Daytime Running Lights and a comprehensive array of over a dozen camera views, which provide enhanced visibility around the truck. These camera views are especially useful for tasks like parking and towing. The Sierra also includes Blind Spot Detection and Lane Departure Warning systems, contributing to safer lane changes and alerting the driver to unintentional lane drift. Furthermore, the Sierra has received a five-star safety rating from the NHTSA, underscoring its dedication to passenger safety.
In summary, both the Ford F-150 and the GMC Sierra 1500 prioritize safety and security, but they do so with distinct features. The F-150 emphasizes pedestrian safety and has earned top safety ratings, while the Sierra offers comprehensive visibility with multiple camera views and includes features like Daytime Running Lights and Blind Spot Detection.
2023 GMC Sierra 1500
- Auxiliary trailer camera
- Bed view camera
- Buckle to Drive
2023 Ford F-150
- Hill Descent Control™
- Pro trailer hitch assist
- Pro Trailer Backup Assist™
Which One Should You Choose?
In the showdown between the Ford F-150 and the GMC Sierra 1500, both trucks come to the table with impressive features, performance options, and technology. However, if we were to make a final recommendation for why you should pick the Ford F-150 over the GMC Sierra, here’s what it comes down to:
- Engine Variety and Power: The Ford F-150 offers a more extensive range of engine options, catering to a wide spectrum of needs and preferences. Whether you’re looking for high towing capacity, fuel efficiency, or a performance-oriented engine, the F-150 has you covered. The High-output 5.2L V8 engine with 700 HP in the F-150 Raptor is a powerhouse, and Ford’s engines deliver impressive performance across the lineup.
- Exterior Design: If you appreciate a truck that makes a bold statement on the road, the F-150’s muscular and innovative exterior design is hard to beat. With its distinctive grille, two-tone paint options, and premium lighting, the F-150 stands out as a visually striking choice. It’s a truck that not only performs but also demands attention wherever you go.
- Interior Design and Technology: Inside the cabin, the F-150 offers a truly luxurious experience. Its opulent interior design, high-quality materials, and advanced infotainment systems make it feel like you’re driving a high-end sedan. Ford’s attention to detail, adaptive ambient lighting, and ergonomic seating adjustments enhance the overall comfort and convenience of the F-150.
- Safety Features: The F-150 impresses with its safety features, including Automatic Emergency Braking and Pedestrian Detection systems. These features contribute to safer city driving and pedestrian safety, earning the F-150 top safety ratings from the NHTSA and the IIHS.
While the GMC Sierra 1500 is undoubtedly a capable truck with its own set of strengths, the Ford F-150’s wider range of engine options, bold exterior design, luxurious interior, and advanced safety features give it the edge. Whether you need a workhorse, a family hauler, or a performance-oriented pickup, the F-150’s versatility and style make it a compelling choice. So, if you’re on the fence between the two, the Ford F-150 should be your pick for a truck that offers a winning combination of power, innovation, and refinement.